Dog
The domestic dog delivers its value with mechanical consistency. Every morning brings the same enthusiastic greeting, regardless of season, solar activity, or atmospheric conditions. The tail will wag. The ears will perk. The full-body celebration of the human's return will occur whether the absence lasted eight hours or eight minutes. This reliability has been documented across 15,000 years of domestication, a track record that few phenomena can match.
Occasional variance occurs, illness may dampen enthusiasm, old age may slow the tail, but these represent deviations from a baseline of remarkable constancy. A healthy dog will provide approximately 5,000 days of predictable companionship across its lifespan, each day conforming to established patterns of greeting, playing, resting, and affection.
Aurora Borealis
The aurora borealis operates on a schedule that humans cannot influence, predict with precision, or negotiate with. Solar cycles span approximately eleven years, with peak activity concentrated in narrow windows that may or may not coincide with human travel plans. The phenomenon requires not merely solar particle ejection but appropriate magnetospheric conditions, clear weather, and the absence of the midnight sun that paradoxically prevents summer viewing in the very latitudes where winter viewing is optimal.
Professional aurora chasers report success rates of approximately 60 percent even in optimal locations during optimal seasons. For casual viewers attempting a single week-long trip, the mathematics become considerably less favourable. The aurora borealis is, in reliability terms, the antithesis of dependable.
VERDICT
Dogs deliver their value every single day without fail. The aurora borealis delivers its value according to cosmic schedules that regard human convenience as irrelevant. In the mathematics of accumulated experience, reliability multiplied by time produces a sum the aurora cannot approach.