Dog
The global pet dog industry generates revenues exceeding $150 billion annually, encompassing food, veterinary care, accessories, insurance, and the inexplicable market for costumes that dogs neither request nor appreciate. Purebred puppies command prices from hundreds to tens of thousands of pounds, depending on breed desirability and the purchaser's susceptibility to marketing.
Beyond direct commerce, dogs provide quantifiable economic services. Security applications, assistance functions, and therapy certifications create employment for trainers, handlers, and administrative staff. The emotional support animal industry alone, regardless of one's views on its legitimacy, represents a multi-billion-pound economic sector.
Hummingbird
Hummingbirds participate in human economies primarily through passive observation infrastructure. The feeder market, whilst modest, generates consistent revenues. Ecotourism operations in Central and South America build entire business models around hummingbird viewing, with dedicated lodges charging premium rates for access to reliable sightings.
Their pollination services, however, represent incalculable economic value. Hummingbirds serve as primary pollinators for numerous commercial crops and ornamental species. The agricultural and horticultural industries would face significant disruption were hummingbird populations to decline substantially. This ecosystem service, whilst not directly monetised, underpins billions in economic activity.
VERDICT
Direct economic impact favours dogs by several orders of magnitude. Hummingbirds' ecosystem services, whilst valuable, remain diffuse and unquantified in traditional economic accounting. Dogs generate measurable revenue at every stage of their existence.