Topic Battle

Where Everything Fights Everything

Gandalf

Gandalf

Wizard who is never late or early.

VS
Wonder Woman

Wonder Woman

Amazonian warrior princess and feminist icon.

Battle Analysis

Combat prowess Wonder Woman Wins
30%
70%
Gandalf Wonder Woman

Gandalf

Gandalf's martial capabilities, whilst oft overlooked, are formidable indeed. His sword Glamdring has tasted goblin blood since the First Age, and he wields the elven blade with considerable skill. However, the wizard's physical confrontations remain deliberately restrained; Tolkien's metaphysics forbid the Istari from matching power directly against Sauron. His most celebrated combat achievement, the defeat of Durin's Bane atop Zirakzigil, required his actual death and divine resurrection. One notes with some amusement that Gandalf's preferred tactics involve inspiring others to fight rather than engaging personally.

Wonder Woman

Diana of Themyscira was literally crafted for combat. Trained from childhood by the greatest warriors in existence, she has mastered every Amazonian fighting technique. Her reflexes approach superhuman velocity, capable of deflecting automatic gunfire with her indestructible bracelets. Armed with the Lasso of Truth, indestructible sword, and shield, she has fought toe-to-toe with Superman himself and emerged victorious. The Pentagon's classified assessments rate her combat efficiency at levels previously thought mythological. Where Gandalf inspires armies, Diana IS an army.

VERDICT

Divine warrior training and superhuman physical abilities decisively outclass the wizard's restrained combat approach
Moral authority Gandalf Wins
70%
30%
Gandalf Wonder Woman

Gandalf

Gandalf embodies moral restraint in the face of absolute power. His refusal to wield the One Ring, despite its apparent utility, demonstrates understanding that righteous ends cannot justify corrupted means. He inspires heroism in others through encouragement rather than compulsion, treating even humble hobbits with profound respect. His famous counsel regarding mercy towards Gollum ultimately saved Middle-earth. Gandalf's moral authority derives from consistency between his principles and actions across millennia.

Wonder Woman

Diana operates from an absolute moral clarity that admits no compromise. Her mission combines warrior ferocity with genuine compassion; she kills when necessary but prefers redemption. The Lasso of Truth reflects her core belief that honesty defeats deception. Her willingness to sacrifice herself for humanity has been demonstrated repeatedly. However, Diana's moral worldview occasionally trends towards Amazonian absolutism, struggling with the moral ambiguities inherent in modern human society.

VERDICT

Nuanced understanding of moral complexity and demonstrated restraint over millennia proves superior
Magical abilities Gandalf Wins
70%
30%
Gandalf Wonder Woman

Gandalf

As a Maiar spirit clothed in mortal form, Gandalf's magical potential technically rivals that of Sauron himself. His mastery of fire magic earned him the epithet Gandalf Stormcrow, and he bears Narya, one of the three elven rings of power. Yet Gandalf's magic operates under strict divine limitations; the Valar forbade the Istari from matching Sauron's power directly. Thus, his observed abilities include fireworks, illumination, telepathic communication, and spectacular but localised combat magic. The true extent of his power remains deliberately obscured.

Wonder Woman

Diana's powers derive from the blessings of six Greek deities: Demeter's strength, Athena's wisdom, Artemis's communion with animals, Aphrodite's beauty, Hestia's sisterhood with fire, and Hermes's speed and flight. This divine portfolio grants superhuman durability, near-light-speed movement, and practical immortality. Additionally, the Lasso of Truth compels absolute honesty, a genuinely supernatural artefact. While not magic in the traditional sense, these abilities manifest through divine channels and exceed mortal comprehension.

VERDICT

True magical manipulation of reality surpasses divinely-granted physical enhancements
Cultural influence Wonder Woman Wins
30%
70%
Gandalf Wonder Woman

Gandalf

Gandalf fundamentally defined the modern wizard archetype. The image of the grey-bearded sage in pointed hat and robes pervades fantasy literature, gaming, and popular culture directly because of Tolkien's creation. An estimated 150 million copies of The Lord of the Rings have sold worldwide, with the film trilogy grossing nearly $3 billion. The character's influence extends to Dungeons and Dragons, Harry Potter, and virtually every subsequent fantasy wizard. Ian McKellen's portrayal earned an Academy Award nomination.

Wonder Woman

As the first major female superhero, Wonder Woman's cultural impact transcends entertainment. She became a feminist icon during the 1970s, gracing the inaugural cover of Ms. Magazine. Gal Gadot's 2017 film earned $822 million globally and sparked important conversations about female representation in action cinema. Diana's influence on young girls' aspirations has been documented in numerous sociological studies. She remains the definitive female superhero against whom all others are measured.

VERDICT

Pioneering feminist icon status and broader social impact outweigh genre-defining influence
Wisdom and strategy Gandalf Wins
70%
30%
Gandalf Wonder Woman

Gandalf

Two millennia of accumulated knowledge grants Gandalf strategic perspectives unavailable to shorter-lived beings. He orchestrated the entire downfall of Sauron through careful manipulation of events spanning decades, placing precisely the right hobbit in precisely the right situation. His understanding of Middle-earth's politics, languages, and hidden histories proved instrumental in the War of the Ring. Crucially, Gandalf's wisdom extends beyond mere knowledge to encompass restraint; he alone among the Istari understood that wielding the One Ring would corrupt absolutely.

Wonder Woman

Diana possesses centuries of education from Themyscira's finest scholars, fluency in numerous ancient and modern languages, and diplomatic training befitting an Amazonian princess. Her strategic acumen has been honed through countless battles and political negotiations. However, Wonder Woman's approach favours directness over subtlety. Where situations demand patient manipulation across decades, her immortal impatience sometimes shows. Nonetheless, her tactical battlefield awareness remains exceptional, having studied warfare for approximately 800 years.

VERDICT

Millennia of subtle orchestration and prophetic insight surpass even exceptional tactical brilliance
👑

The Winner Is

Gandalf

52 - 48

This remarkable confrontation between Tolkien's wandering wizard and DC's divine warrior ultimately resolves in Gandalf's favour, though by the narrowest of margins. Wonder Woman's physical superiority remains unquestionable; in direct combat, Diana would likely prevail within moments. Her cultural significance as a feminist icon carries profound real-world importance that should not be understated.

However, Gandalf's victory emerges from a deeper understanding of what heroism truly means. His two millennia of patient wisdom, his masterful orchestration of events across decades, and his profound moral authority collectively outweigh brute divine power. The wizard understands that true victory often requires losing battles to win wars, a subtlety that occasionally eludes the Amazonian warrior.

In the final analysis, wisdom tempered by humility proves more enduring than divine might wielded with righteous certainty.

Gandalf
52%
Wonder Woman
48%

Share this battle

More Comparisons